
TradeWinds Island Grand
Best for active family beach vacations with multiple pools, watersports and a broad lineup of on-site dining and kids' activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
TradeWinds Island Grand is a large, family-focused Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach with multiple pools, water activities and many on-site restaurants. Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection is an upscale villa-style marina hotel on Holmes Beach (Anna Maria Island) for travelers who want apartment-style rooms and marina access.
Updated

Best for active family beach vacations with multiple pools, watersports and a broad lineup of on-site dining and kids' activities.

Best for travelers wanting upscale villa-style lodging, direct marina access and a quieter Anna Maria Island setting.
When TradeWinds Island Grand wins: choose TradeWinds if you want a resort built around pools, a waterslide, a floating water park experience, lots of organized activities for kids and multiple on-site restaurants and bars. It’s designed for families and guests who want an active beach-resort base.
When Waterline Villas & Marina wins: pick Waterline if you prefer villa-style accommodations with full kitchens, a small-property feel, on-site dock/marina access and a quieter Anna Maria Island location. It’s a better fit for guests who want self-catered rooms and marina conveniences.
Bottom line: TradeWinds is the busier, full-service family resort with extensive public amenities and programmed activities; Waterline Villas & Marina is a smaller, upscale villa option on Anna Maria Island focused on space, kitchens and marina access. Choose based on whether you want a high-activity resort experience or a quieter villa-with-marina stay.
| Category | TradeWinds Island Grand | Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, busy family beach resort with many public amenities and programmed activities. | Small upscale villa-style waterfront property with marina access and quieter pace. |
| Location | Gulf-front on St. Pete Beach (5500 Gulf Blvd). | Waterfront on Holmes Beach, Anna Maria Island (5325 Marina Drive). |
| Size (rooms) | About 381 rooms across a large resort footprint (multiple buildings). | 37 individually furnished guestrooms/villas. |
| Ages | All-ages resort; family-focused with kids' club and children's pool. | All-ages (not adults-only); villa rooms and family-friendly facilities available. |
| Pools & water | Five outdoor pools, two hot tubs, dedicated children's pool, seasonal floating water park and waterslide. | One outdoor pool; marina and walkways to water; kayaking and on-site personal motorized watercraft available. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (coastal bistro, Italian, tacos, pizza, beach bars, coffee, ice cream). | One on-site restaurant (The Chateau Anna Maria) plus room service during limited hours and bar/lounge. |
| Spa & fitness | Serenity Sands Spa (onsite services) and 24/7 fitness center; fitness classes and beach yoga offered. | Fitness facilities on site; spa/beauty services nearby rather than a large in-house spa. |
| Rooms & kitchens | Hotel rooms and suites; some villas — room types include Villa and Studio Suite options (no universal full-kitchen claim in every room). | Villa units with kitchens (full-sized refrigerators/freezers and ovens) and Egyptian cotton sheets. |
| Parking & access | On-site pay-by-plate parking (daily fee). | Self parking (surcharge) available on site. |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly (dogs allowed, fee applies). | Pets allowed with a per-accommodation fee; service animals exempt. |
TradeWinds sits directly on a Gulf of Mexico beach at 5500 Gulf Blvd in St. Pete Beach.
Choose TradeWinds for immediate Gulf-front access and a classic St. Pete Beach resort location.
Waterline Villas & Marina is on the waterfront in Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island with direct marina and dock access.
Choose Waterline if you prefer Anna Maria Island’s quieter island vibe and the convenience of an on-site marina.
TradeWinds offers a mix of rooms, studio suites and named villas across buildings on the resort grounds.
Pick TradeWinds for a range of family-oriented room layouts and easy access to resort facilities.
Waterline’s accommodations are villa-style two-bedroom units with full kitchens and living space.
Choose Waterline if you want larger villa-style rooms with kitchens for self-catering or longer stays.
TradeWinds runs multiple restaurants and bars across the property, from full-service to casual counters and beachfront bars.
TradeWinds suits travelers who want many in-resort dining choices without leaving the property.
Waterline features The Chateau Anna Maria as its on-site dining option and limited room service.
Waterline is better for guests who prefer villa kitchens or a quieter single-restaurant setting.
TradeWinds centers around multiple pool areas and on-the-water attractions for families and active guests.
TradeWinds is the choice for families and guests who want many pool options and organized water activities.
Waterline offers one outdoor pool and direct marina/dock access for boats and watercraft.
Waterline suits travelers who prioritize marina access and boating rather than multiple resort pools.
TradeWinds provides a named on-site spa plus fitness options and scheduled wellness classes.
Choose TradeWinds for a fuller spa and fitness program plus casual evening options on property.
Waterline lists fitness facilities and points to nearby spa/beauty services rather than a large in-house spa.
Waterline is better for quiet evenings and guests who will use local spa partners or in-room relaxation.

TradeWinds — multiple pools (including a children’s pool), waterslide, kids' activities and family dining options.

Waterline — two-bedroom villas with full kitchens and living areas for longer or self-catered stays.

Waterline — on-site dock and marina with personal motorized watercraft and boating access.

TradeWinds — multiple restaurants and beachfront bars across the resort to suit different tastes and occasions.
TradeWinds is set up for families with multiple pools, a children's pool, a waterslide, kids’ craft classes and many family-friendly dining options.
Waterline is focused on marina access and lists on-site docking and personal motorized watercraft; choose it if marina convenience is a priority.
Yes — the Waterline Villas listing specifies kitchens with full-sized refrigerators/freezers and ovens in guestrooms.
Yes. Both list pet policies that allow pets for a fee; check each property's current fees and breed/size restrictions before booking.
Explore how TradeWinds Island Grand stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·